In a sentence like:
“你给我那一杯水” You would translate it something like: Get me a glass of water.
How is the "给我" in the sentence “你给我滚” supposed to be translated?
Should it just be "Get lost / P*ss off" and just ignore the "给我" part?
Tell me more
×
Chinese Language & Usage Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for
students, teachers, and linguists wanting to discuss the finer points of the Chinese language. It's 100% free, no registration required.
|
|
|||||||||||
|
|
Adding to Ciaocibai's answer: "你给我滚" could be same to "给我滚" and then further reduced to "滚". In both "你给我滚" and "给我滚", personally, I think the "给我" part is used to make emphasis on strong emotions, such as contempt or strong anger. It will therefore depends on the tune/context to translate it. E.g. "给我滚一边去", can be used by a gangster head to someone else who is not important, to show his/her contempt and therefore show his/her superiority in the gang. Or when a father is really angry at his son who commit a crime, he is furious and shouts out loud "给我滚!" |
|||
|
|
|
On grammar, “你给我 [doing something]” means: I am ordering you [doing something].
That's natural Chinese:) |
||||
|
|
I see the 给我 as essentially having the same meaning in both sentences, a meaning which could be summarised as 'for me' . That is, the literal meaning of the sentence is 'Fuck off for me!', or 'I want you to fuck off!'. But this is not being polite, not at all. When you shout at someone in English, 'I want you out of here!', adding 'I want you...' isn't an attempt to be nice; it's a strong expression of the speaker's will. In translation the 给我 can be safely ignored. |
|||
|
|
Too many options, other possible candidates are:
给我 used in such context is really just for emphasis and not required to be explicitly translated, just note the essence of it. |
||||
|
|
|
A LITERAL translation would be something like: "Give me space!" But its real (impolite) connotation is more like "get lost" or "buzz off." |
|||
|
|
|
I'd say it is like 'you get away from me', with the 给我 part just meaning get away. I suppose if you were being polite you could translate it as 'give me some space', but to be honest I think it's pretty subjective. |
|||
