Take the 2-minute tour ×
Chinese Language Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for students, teachers, and linguists wanting to discuss the finer points of the Chinese language. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I'm curious as to why the stroke order of is different to the stroke order of .

One page I found ( and stroke order) theorises that the reason is because has "touching" strokes and there is a hook that "points" to the second stroke, so it could not itself be the second stroke.

This seems to be a decent theory, though I'd like to know if anybody has a concrete source proving (or disproving) this rule. It does note that it only applies for cases where the strokes touch, so it does not count in cases like .

Any insights?

share|improve this question
3  
The idea of the stroke order is to make the character you write be more structural thus beautiful. The first stroke will always be the initial guidance of the whole character, so in this case which stroke is first depends on whether this stroke can make your character's major structure be certain. In this case, 力's right portion is more certain, whereas 九 which can be considered as left-right structure, should be written as 人,八,大 etc. –  tomriddle_1234 Feb 21 at 1:05
    
九 is more of a unique one. I've always written 九 the other way around though. Would say that it is an exceptional case. –  user3992 Feb 21 at 5:46
    
I'm going to have to guess but I think the brush stroke order (笔画顺序) has to do with "cursive writing" (草书). The general rule is horizontal before vertical but when writing in cursive the flow of writing is better the other way around for some characters. 九 flows better with vertical first and slipping into the horizontal. –  amateur Feb 21 at 12:44

1 Answer 1

up vote 5 down vote accepted

About this question, you can consult Guobao Wang's summary:

1.只有横折钩类与撇相遇:先写横折钩,例刀、力、万 、方、乃、杨。

2.其他横折类与撇相遇:都先写撇,例如及(横折折撇 ),几(横折弯),九(横斜钩)、匕(竖折弯)。

translate into English:

1.Only when uppermost and rightmost lines with a left hook cross with right-to-left diagonals(ノ): uppermost and rightmost lines with a left hook is written first. For example: "刀", "力", "万", "方", "乃", "杨".

2.In other situation uppermost and rightmost lines cross with right-to-left diagonals(ノ): right-to-left diagonals is written first. For example: "及", "几", "九", "匕".

Anyway, maybe the following links will offer you more information about stroke order rules.

1.现代汉语通用字笔顺规范(official version);

2.现代汉语通用字笔顺规范.pdf;

3.现代汉语通用字笔顺规范;

4.《现代汉语通用字笔顺规范》电子版;

5."火"的笔顺.

Besides, the website 汉典 is perhaps useful to you.

share|improve this answer
1  
+1. I don't know why this answer is voted down. 现代汉语通用字笔顺规范(official version) should be considered as the most authoritative source in mainland China. If there's anything wrong in the answer, could the down-voter explain what it is? Thanks. –  Stan Feb 25 at 6:20
    
Thanks, this is exactly the kind of answer I was looking for! –  Ming Feb 25 at 6:24
    
@Stan I didn't downvote, but being official doesn't equal to correctness. I can easily find wrong orders that are unacceptable in calligraphy from 现代汉语通用字笔顺规范. But in another perspective, offical source is always correct due to the authoritativeness. –  agriprop Feb 25 at 10:26
1  
@agriprop, can you point out what are the unacceptables ? –  tomriddle_1234 Feb 26 at 0:53
1  
@tomriddle_1234 I studied calligraphy since 4 years old, and knew that the official reference was wrong ever since. I've even had countless arguments with teachers, who told me to follow the textbook. For your reference: bbs.tianya.cn/post-454-12035-1.shtml zhihu.com/question/22652195. Someone might argue that stroke orders in calligraphy don't matter in real life, but it does matter, because that's how the characters are supposed to be written. –  agriprop Feb 27 at 6:49

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.