1

What is the best understanding and (English) translation of 空无?

汉语大词典:

佛教语。谓一切事物从因缘生,唯心所造,了无自性

《维摩经菩萨行品》: "观於空无而不舍大悲。"

There are a lot of religious, if you will, concepts in here that I just can't seem to wrap my mind around.

ABC dictionary defines it as unreality in English, but I'm not finding anything to do with unreality + Buddhaism. Which leads me to believe that ABC's definition is more akin to 汉语大词典's second definition:

指虚无之境。

Which we don't need to discuss, here, at all.

  • 2
    What about nihility? Or maybe sunyata, abhava. – Stan Dec 28 '14 at 9:02
  • I believe Buddhism concepts are deeply rooted in its own philosophical framework, which is a good reason for inventing new words instead of overloading well-defined words from a different framework. – NS.X. Dec 29 '14 at 0:40
2

Emptiness and Nothingness.

Now lets dissect the definition:

谓一切事物从因缘生,唯心所造,了无自性

  • 从因缘生 -- 因 is the inner reason, 缘 is the outer reason, the two combined together, meaning the Ultimate Reason, is the cause of everything. Hence 一切事物从因缘生. You might want to think of it as dialectic reasoning, and you can do that.
  • 唯心所造 says that everything is created by the Heart, the thinking device. It's idealism stripped to the bone.
  • 自性 is the quality or essence of existence itself, since everything is caused by Reason and created by Heart, their Essence is null. Simply put, they don't Exist, hence 了无自性.

Even with a worldview like this, Buddhists still hold the Great Compassion, hence 观於空无而不舍大悲。

Then you ask what is Reason, what is Heart, and what is the Essence of Existence. The Buddha picks up a flower and smiles, and suddenly you reach Enlightenment.

Or you don't, in fact it's one of Buddha's disciples that does. I have friends struggling with these for decades, but still haven't reached anything remarkable, and I daresay, it's a complete waste of time.

As for translation, it depends on what you are translating. If you translate Buddhism classic texts, it's better to use Sanskrit words. If you translate a novel, or some random article with Buddhism references, use the capital like I did, or like Roger Zelazny did in his novel Lord of Light. It's a great book by the way.

1

空 means “empty”,无 means “not exist” ,“空无”的常识性(non philosophical)理解就是 nothing.

那个unreality应该是philosophical interpretation,it means 不真实的,虚幻的,phantom,可以理解为“空无” related the real world, which is closed to meaning of "空无“ in 佛教。Nothing for the real world, but also has something in the phantom meaning.

  • 1
    Strongart,你啃老十年,罪在不赦,四处诈骗,恶贯满盈,诱奸妇女,罪不容诛。你这种恶劣行径,竟然还敢谈什么”空无“吗? – YHBKJ Apr 13 '15 at 5:19
0

Maybe you mean 虚空无形 concepts of Buddhism. Basically Buddhists say, nothing exists, even emptiness. It is not possible to grasp the non dual nature of duality with a logical mind.

If you read The Platform Sutra of 惠能 you will understand more. Or the Diamond Sutra.

http://www.fodian.net/world/6th_sutra.html http://www.fodian.net/world/platform_sutra_yampolsky.pdf

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.