8

Is there any difference in connotation/region/modernity/etc. between questions ending in 吗 and affirmative/negative questions?

For example, does:

你很累吗?

connote something different than:

你累不累?

And does the following have a third connotation?: 你很累没有?

  • I think it's also worth noting that the X不X can occur in the middle of a sentence, eg 你现在有钱了,是不是嫌弃我了? – goPlayerJuggler Aug 24 at 10:15
3

There's also 嘛 and 吗. Practically, there is little difference between the two, aside from the pronunciation.

吗 is most used in questions where speaker is usually neutral about the question.

嘛, although not applicable in your given example, it can be used to question or affirm. I.e., used with to express emotional context (positive or negative given the context) (e.g., 你这是干吗? = questioning, vs. 你这是干嘛? = complaining) or to express certainty with something (e.g. 很贵嘛! or 不错嘛!)

In terms of connotation, "你累不累?" is the same as "你很累吗?" They both mean to ask if the person is tired or not, in a neutral tone.

你很累没有 seems a bit awkward grammatically. The way it's structured implies a statement rather than a question. You are probably looking to use 吧 in this case. E.g., 你很累吧 (You're pretty tired, huh/right/aren't you?), would be more appropriate here. 吧 is used at the end of a sentence when you are uncertain of something you can say.

There is also 呢, which is often used at the end of an interrogative sentence. e.g., 为什么...呢? 怎么...呢? Take note that 呢 is NOT interchangeable with 吗.

| improve this answer | |
1

你很累没有?

The structure of 你xx沒有? is quite common for native user.

E.g. 你吃飯(了)沒有? 你上學(了)沒有? 你買房(了)沒有? 你結婚(了)沒有? etc...

Back to 你很累没有? I believe it’s understandable for native user. If you use 你累了沒有?, it would be more fluent than 你很累没有?.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.