2

I and my Chinese friend are discussing about the meaning of "她是笨蛋的学生” So, can u guys tell me which meaning is correct, or which meaning is popularly used: "She is a fool student", or "She is the student of a fool". I mean, the "笨蛋” refers to the teacher or the student?! Thank you for concerning.

  • 1
    As 笨蛋的 is not a valid adjective, "She is the student of a fool" would be the only grammatical way to interpret the sentence. – Stan Jul 13 '16 at 6:57
4

If the sentence is 她是笨蛋学生 or 她是笨学生, it would mean She is a fool student, but since there is a in between, 笨蛋 is a noun that refers to a person, and not an adjective anymore. So She is the student of a fool makes better sense.

  • Feels more likely that the writer made a mistake. – SOFe Jul 13 '16 at 8:28
0

I am native Chinese. I have to say that in practice such saying is very unlikely to be used. This is swearing at someone.

For a Chinese language learner, it is not the path to go to dig into such things.

Chinese language is not like western languages in that it is very simple in grammar. There is no time tense for verbs. There is no part of speech changes for pronouns etc.

Therefore, do not dig into grammar. Grammar is extremely simple.

0

的 is of, so 笨蛋 is refers to teacher

0

It is very likely this was intended to have an adjectival meaning: "she is one dummy of a student." It is a VERY casual way of talking, much more likely to be sent as a text message or post than spoken, but I have seen LOTS of this kind of thing online. Think of it as a Chinese correlate to the pidgin English so many people use when they are posting carelessly. Don't use it in your assignments, your teacher might have a conniption fit.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.