2

Question: Is there any relationship between 田, 由, 甲, and 申?

  • (tián) = field; it seems rarely used
  • (yóu) = ???; I've only seen it as a radical for (yóu) = oil
  • (jiǎ) = nails, as in fingernails 手指甲 (shǒuzhǐjiǎ); it's also a radical in 鸭子 (yāzi) = duck
  • (shēn) = ???; I've seen it used in 申请 (shēnqǐng) = application

The characters appear similar, so I tend to get them confused often. It might be there's a reason these characters are similar which might help me remember them better (or there might be no meaningful relationship).

  • cf。日加一笔可以变成什么字?zhidao.baidu.com/question/177588211.html – user6065 Jun 1 '17 at 3:15
  • don't see modern glyph, we should see original glyph instead. enter your characters at zdic.net/z/1f/zy/7531.htm to check the most ancient glyph. – Daniel Yang Jun 7 '17 at 4:28
  • No meaningful relationship. 由 is contentious in its meaning. The upper surrounding box in 甲 was a Shang king royalty mark (the character 甲 was almost identical in shape to the ancient 七 and modern 十 without the box), and without this box it was a picture of marks on split bark/outer seed coatings > hard outer coating > nail, armour. 申 is the original character for 电 (/*lˤi[n]-s/), and depicts forked lightning; the meaning extend (/*l̥i[n]/) is a semantic extension. – dROOOze Apr 15 at 17:43
3

The origin of 田 was a pictograph of a rice field

http://www.zdic.net/z/1e/zy/7530.htm rice field

The primary meaning of 田 is 'rice field'

~

The origin of 由 was a pictograph of a sprout

http://www.zdic.net/z/1f/zy/7531.htm oil lamp

The primary meaning of 由 is 'from; begin with'

~

The origin of 甲 was a pictograph of the intersection of a planted armor

http://www.zdic.net/z/1f/zy/7532.htm planted armor

The primary meaning of 甲 is 'armor; top class'

~

The origin of 申 was a pictograph of a man kneeing with pleading hands (to plead to gods)

http://www.zdic.net/z/1f/zy/7533.htm man kneeing with pleading hands

The primary meaning of 申 is 'plead'

| improve this answer | |
0

They are not related.

In Oracle bone script, they are completely different shapes.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.