4

Wiktionary gives the stroke order for as:

Stroke order for 男

I'm wondering if it's wrong to merge the two vertical strokes like this:

writing 男 by combining two strokes

Question: Is it legitimate to write 男 merging the two vertical strokes?

  • 1
    As long as you know the correct stoke order of '男', it is not a problem to write it in a slightly modified form ( in hand writing) as a personal style. I write my last name 'Ho' with the vertical stoke in 'H' extends and touching the 'O' . – Tang Ho Nov 4 '17 at 6:50
  • 1
    as long as user does not forget the correct number of strokes – user6065 Nov 4 '17 at 12:19
  • 1
    As long as there're no minimal pairs, I would not pay attention to prescriptivist advice; actually, different typefaces and fonts merge them. – GJC Nov 4 '17 at 13:12
3

The simple answer is 'wrong'. 男 is 田 + 力.

It might be ok for daily writing, but it would be wrong for any type of exams.

2

I think your question can only be answered if framed right, i.e.

When I write a given character this or that way,

  • will people be able to read it?
  • will I get bad marks in an exam?
  • will many people consider it wrong?
  • am I following/violating a long-standing tradition?

and so on. One way to answer your question is the easy way out: just adhere to a well-known, published standard. In that case, there's clearly one right and many wrong ways to write a character, and @dan basically answered it: "The simple answer is 'wrong'. 男 is 田 + 力". Unfortunately, those prescriptive standards are often wrong or problematic themselves.

The more interesting way to answer your question is to look at how writers in the past and present actually do write a given character, and then decide whether you want to break or bend the apparent rules or rather follow them. In your specific case, I'd look at the many samples given at http://shufa.guoxuedashi.com/7537/1/ (kaishu), http://shufa.guoxuedashi.com/7537/2/ (xingshu) and http://shufa.guoxuedashi.com/7537/3/ (caoshu); I think what you can easily see there is that while there's plenty of evidence for a historical variant of 男 that has something like 𠠲 under the 田, there's not a single sample where 田 and 力 share the vertical stroke.

This leads me to answer your question with "you probably don't want to write 男 with a single vertical stroke because you'd be the only one to do so".

@nichijou's answer ("you break the consistency of writing any character with a 田") is generally reasonable, but then there are singular characters that are habitually or even prescriptively written in ways that are inconsistent, e.g. look at 所; it is often written like 𫠦 even in kaishu, and at any rate the left part retains the form 戶 although it should be 户 in the PRC.

1

even for daily writing, I think it's a bad choice, since you break the consistency of writing any character with a 田

1

Wrong, even if you want to be faster or lazily.

It is a convention that some strokes can be linked, some can not, some components can be reduced, some can not. If people break that convention in daily writings, he will not get a good impression from others.

If you don't know how, it is always a good habit to write strokes one by one.

enter image description here

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.