1

I am trying to learn Cantonese.

I want to be able to say (speak, not write) after a meal:

I am full.

Which I could translate directory to:

Ngo5 hai6 baau2

But, my local (student in HK) friend says this is incorrect and that the following is preferred:

Ngo5 hou2 baau2

Which I would read as

I very full

Sentences like this come up quite often, where sometimes I need to say the verb hai6, or sometimes a "degree" such as hou2 and additionally gei(unsure of tone or meaning) has been suggested.

What is the correct structure of a sentence where you want to tell somebody your current state of being?

  • 1
    You wouldn't use hai6 to tell people you are tired or hungry or thirty or full - you would use hai6 to tell people you are a doctor or a teacher or a principle or a big brother. hou2 while seemingly meaning very is often used with things like tired or hungry or thirty or full to make the sentence more natural and understandable - you shouldn't take it literally. Like your friend suggested Ngo5 hou2 baau2 just means I'm full. – user3306356 Nov 8 '17 at 8:39
2

ngo5 hai6 baau2

--> 我係飽 is "unnatural", hmmm, non-native way to express.

ngo5 hou2 baau2

--> 我好飽

native way to say it :)

just like the english "being", in other language, the verb changes:

i'm 70 years old

(being is used to describe age), which is translated to:

j'ai 70 ans

(avoir [to have], is used, not être [to be]; then, in cantonese, it should be:

我七十歲

technically, the verb is omitted

gei(unsure of tone or meaning)

it is 嘅(u+5605), roughly "my, his, her, their"; ask you friend how to pronounce it ;-)

last, i would suggest learning cantonese from dramas, videos, and news, forget grammar books.

have fun :)

  • Hmm I think I must have misheard/misremembered gei then, I thought it maybe "a little"? As in: I am a little hungry. Thanks for the response! Not sure if you happen to know Spanish or not, but it seems like hai6 vs hou2 is similar to ser vs estar? – Ell Nov 8 '17 at 9:15
  • spanish? no lah :( "i am a little hungry" would be: 我有啲餓. 啲(u+5572) means "a little", pronounced similar to "d" in "a, b, c, d", according to english. humanum.arts.cuhk.edu.hk/Lexis/lexi-mf/search.php?word=啲 – 水巷孑蠻 Nov 8 '17 at 9:50

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.