4

From what I can tell, 一个年 is completely wrong because you can never use a classifier together with . The situation is different from a phrase like 一个朋友.

My question is: why? Is there a reason why is different from 朋友 like this? Are there other nouns which behave like ?

Or is really syntactically more like ? Is actually usable as a measure word? Can you for example say 一年时间 or 两年工作?

  • see any grammar: CCG:2.11 Missing measure words ...one possibility is that the noun itself may be a measure. E.g. 一个人,一人,e。g。一人船,一个星期、一星期,e。g。一星期假期,there is some ambiguity with temporal nouns, some are only nouns, some may be both nouns and measures, while others may be only used as measures: 一个小时,一小时,一个钟头,*一钟头,*一个天,一天,一个礼拜,*一礼拜,一周,一个周,一个月, 一月 (January),*一个年,一年 – user6065 Nov 20 '17 at 21:25
  • also note 数词+名词短语做定语, e.g. 一人船, 四贴袋男用套装 chinese.stackexchange.com/questions/14657/… – user6065 Nov 20 '17 at 21:55
  • You may speak 一日/一天, 一星期/一个星期/一周/一个周, 一月(depending on context)/一个月, 一年, you may not speak 一个日/一个天, 一个年. The word 一月 would mean one month or January. If you say 这一月, it means this one month, or you may speak with second tone, , and stress the character 月, it means one month but not January. January reads as (first tone) yue (untoned). – 賈可 Jacky Nov 21 '17 at 5:14
2

You cannot say 一个年, but you can say 一个年头

The difference between 年 and 年头 had been explained here Understanding 年頭 in context

Yes, 年 itself can be a classifier '一年时间' and '两年工夫' are both valid

2

As the other answers said, 年 is a measure word when it refers to 'year', i.e. 一年时间, 两年工作.

Well, when 年 is used as a noun, it specifically refers to the Spring Festival, 新年.

For example,

你在中国过了几个(新)年了? // How many Spring Festivals have you spent in China

这(一)个年怎么过 or 这(一)个新年怎么过 // How are we going to celebrate this Spring Festivals?

  • should be the accepted answer. Others failed to consider when 年 is a noun, 一个年 is correct. – jf328 Nov 22 '17 at 13:14
  • 年 may also means a monster, which is a noun – tsh Nov 24 '17 at 7:57
  • 新年 is a countable noun, 年 is a short form of it. The correct phrasing should be "你在中国过了几个新年了", writing "你在中国过了几个年了 could be "你在中国过了几个年头了 ". In short, '年' being a noun only when it is the short form of either '新年' or '年头'. Finally, saying '一个年' is a short form of '一个年头' or '一个新年'-- people usually don't shorten these two phrases like that. – Tang Ho Nov 24 '17 at 10:00
  • the noun 年 by itself doesn't take classifier, – Tang Ho Nov 24 '17 at 10:10
  • @TangHo, 一个年 is usually short for 一个新年, but not 一个年头. 年头 should not be elided. – dan Nov 24 '17 at 10:19
1

Because 年 is a count word or classifier. In our language it is called 量词. You can't use a count word to count another count word, like we never say 一个粒 or 一条只. But you use the double count words to express every, like 一年年 means every year.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.