6

I recently encountered 打不死 as the title of a column in a US Chinese language newspaper. Asking my Chinese language teacher, she gave the literal translation of "beaten but not dead", meaning something like immortal or resilient. She wasn't clear about this being a common phrase (she's from Shanghai if it's relevant) so I would like to know about that and in what context it may be used.

6

打不死 is of a fine, common idiomatic structure X不Y, where X is some verb that cannot be completed, e.g.:

  • 吃不完 (implying that there is too much food to be finished)
  • 做不動 (implying that you are unable to finish doing a difficult task)
  • 找不到 (implying that some object is too hard to find)

Immortal or resilient are the correct implied meanings of 打不死, but beaten but not dead is problematic, as the word beaten carries two slightly different nuances:

  • Struck or been hit, which is the literal translation of「打」;
  • Been defeated (e.g. "I've beaten you at this game")

When I hear the phrase beaten but not dead, it sounds like someone's been in a fight and was defeated in the fight, but managed to escape with their life. 打不死 does not carry any notion that one side was defeated in a fight - rather, it carries the notion that one side is extremely resilient to being attacked.

2

It's often used as an adjectival phrase (打不死的xxx) as in 打不死的小强, meaning someone who can not be defeated or killed. 小强 roughly means newbie.

When it's used as a verbal phrase, it means: one can not be killed by means of beating. For example, 你打不死他: you can not beat and kill him.

  • Doesn’t 小强 mean cockroach? – user3306356 Dec 13 '18 at 12:52
  • 小强,baike.baidu.com/item/小强/3270?fr=aladdin 多指蟑螂,据说最早把蟑螂叫小强是在广东香港地区,“小强”这个别名源于周星驰的电影《唐伯虎点秋香》。蟑螂有很多名称,其实正式名称为蜚蠊。Even if it started out as a topolectical thing, I’m pretty sure most mainlanders know it now. – user3306356 Dec 13 '18 at 13:02
  • @user3306356, i'm not sure the etymology. 但在玩游戏的时候,小强经常指一些新手或者新人但又实力还可以的选手. – dan Dec 13 '18 at 13:05
1

For a real-life context, to quote a line from the lyric of Hong Kong rock band Beyond's 不再犹豫 (Hesitate No More):

自信打不死的心态活到老

which roughly translates to I believe I will live all my life in the spirit of 打不死.

0

打不死 literally means "can't be beaten to death"

Simple translation would be "invulnerable" ( incapable of being wounded, hurt, or damaged)

'打不死' mainly describe a tough, resilience and often combative character

James bond in 007 movies and John McClane in Die Hard are typical '打不死' hero characters

Unlike 不败 or 無敵 (invincible), a 打不死 doesn't necessary to be an overpowering character

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.