19

There are multiple uses for both 了 and 过, so it's good you are just asking about usage to express past action or events. 了, as you probably know, is often used to express a change of state. Perhaps somewhat relatedly, 了 can be used to express a past action that is still ongoing. But 过 cannot: when 过 is used to refer to a past event, that past event must ...


12

I think Chinese textbooks should start their 了 sections with this: 了 is not about time. 了 is not about tense. Goto 1. You are only concerned with 了 as an the aspect marker, aka completed action 了, or perfect aspect 了, so: "昨天去商店" and "昨天去了商店" are both valid verb phrases. The second one explicitly states that the action was completed, whereas the first one ...


12

The order where 了 appears in the sentence is important: when placed at the end of a sentence, it represents a change of state (it has nothing to do with tenses); when placed at the end of a verb, it represents a completed action. Using the examples in your question: 他们给我写信了 They wrote me a letter. (This is the first time I receive a letter from them.) ...


9

Just to expand on Hugh’s answer a bit. To understand what’s wrong with ‘我作天去商店.’ standing alone, we could translate it as ‘Yesterday I was going to the shop.’ Speaking English, if you said this and just stopped, the listener would think, well so what? There are some verbs which are not used with 了 where a time phrase is enough to show past action. For ...


8

You have to remember, unlike in English, we do not have past tense for verbs in Chinese grammar. Both "is" and "was" is written as "是" in Chinese. "是" in "她是好老师" could be "is" or "was". We really don't care which, because it is presumed readers can find out the sentence is in past or present tense by looking into the context. For example: "她以前是个好老师"(she ...


7

Yes, `one day' can certainly be used to refer to events in the past as well. A better translation of "One day, the boy went for a walk" could be "有一天, 那个男孩外出散步", or less literary, "那个男孩出门走路". "去了走路" is not grammatical, "去走路了" and "走路去了" are grammatical but do not fit in here.


5

「我病了。」 can be a subtle expression which implies different meaning based its context. It can mean, but may not be limited to, these: Present status that I'm not so well. Past status that I was ill. Completive sense that I've been ill for a while. 「病」 the word is a common one, which can imply from a minor ailment to a mortal blow. Again, this depends on the ...


5

If the form 我看了一本书 is correct then what role is 了 playing here and why does it sound to me like past tense with a not-a-tense-marker indicating tense? '了' in "我看了一本书" is a [aspect marker] indicating completed action. 我看一本书 = I read a book In 我看了一本书, the action '看' is completed, which imply 看 is not in present tense but in past tense. Also, depend on ...


5

Neither. If you used to be x and you're not any more you'd just use a construct like: 以前很x like: (我)以前很胖 Of course, 很 doesn't necessarily mean really or very, but if you want to change it to 有点 that's cool too: (我)以前有点(儿)胖


4

曾经 is more equivalent to "once" in English as in the sentence Once we were the best friends. It is used to: express the fact the sentence is talking about happened in the past. if the predicate verb is a durative verb*, express that fact can't be experienced(经=experience) by the speaker(doesn't last) any more. , the speaker implies that the ...


4

You have a few options. As @NS.X. pointed out 一直 is a good one, but you can also use 一向, e.g.我一向很懒。I have always been very lazy. 向来, e.g. 她向来就是个书呆子。 She has always been a bookworm. 从来 is more likely used together with 不 or 没 conveying negation, of course that is not necessary. A conjecture of mine: 一直 is often used with a certain beginning in the ...


3

I would say, as a Chinese, that Chinese language doesn't express tenses as explicitly and clearly as English does in most cases. Your translation of the first sentence(我在北京住了六个月) can be taken in both ways, in which case we figure out the tense by context. Past tense would be a better guess, though. To remove uncertainties, you can say: 我在北京住过六个月。I lived in ...


3

(1)我在北京住过6个月。我在北京住了六个月 seems ok too (2)我已经在北京住了6个月。 as regards word order if 在 follows 住: 我(已经)住在了北京(6个月) In fact 在了 seems to be a familiar sequence,also one can find example sentences online with 住在了,iciba immediately produces 3 of them, here is the first: 当他年老的时候他住在了一个群岛上, 远离这里. In case 了 is replaced by 过,it seems the corresponding word order has to ...


3

了 functions both as aspectual and modal particle, in the former case it occurs after the verb, in the latter at the end of the sentence. In images 1,3 the completed aspect of the action is referred to, in images 2,4 了 occurs at the end of the sentence to indicate a change(the emergence of a new situation, change in understanding, opinion,ideas, or action, ...


3

This is a frequent type of question, perhaps someone can ask a more general question that would allow a more generally useful answer. As a step toward that, I'll try to raise a couple of general points here. First, past tense is not a vocabulary item in English. It is a type of verbal inflection. Chinese does not have this type of verbal inflection. Answers ...


3

There's several explanations already, but IMO they are just expanding on your question and not really fixing it, the straight up answer and the most fluent way is this. Q: 你怎么知道的?(How do you know that?) A: 我从一本书上看的。(I read from a book.) "从" translates to "from", "一本" is needed because you are specifying you read from A book and you know which book it is, ...


3

[沒+ X(v)] is the negative form of [有+ X(v)] (replace 有 with 沒) Example: [沒殺人] (did not kill someone) [有殺人]( have killed someone / did kill someone) *Replace 有 with 沒 [沒有+ X(v)] is also the negative form of [有+X(v)] (add 沒 before 有) Example: [沒有殺人] (did not kill someone) [有殺人]( have killed someone / did kill someone) *Add 沒 before 有 Simply ...


2

Just as 已经 means "already" and emphasizes the sense of the completed action particle 了, 曾经 means "once" and emphasizes the sense of 过. I disagree with Bob that 曾经 means already here; in general "once" or "ever" is a better translation. I would render your sentence as "I once studied two years of Chinese in Beijing."


2

In my opinion, you can use "了" right after the verb or at the end of the sentence when "了" is used to show the past tense. However, in your case, that's another thing that I want to clarify. I think, "去面试" should be treated as one phrasal verb, something like the phrasal verb "go fishing", "go shopping" in English.Here "面试" (interview) is a noun which has a ...


2

I think whatever you put 了 after verb or at the end of of sentence. they both means the action is finished or completed. It is past tense. So, 我吃了巧克力 and 我吃巧克力了 just means I ate chocolate. But there is a slight difference between them . 我吃了巧克力 means to emphasize the verb ate. 我吃巧克力了 means to emphasize ate chocolate. Hope it helpful.


2

“了” is a special character usually meaning "finished" or "something happen in the future", we can summarize these points: 1) For a verb that can be persistant, “了” means “begin to do something immediately on spoken” (usually SVO+了): 妈妈,我*做功课了*;做完功课后我出去散步。(Mon, I'll start homeworking, then I'll walk outside). However, if SV了+O(Subject+Verb+了+Object),mostly ...


2

This will not answer your question but shed some light to the mystery of the 了 particle. 了 does not mean past tense. It denotes **CHANGE**. 以前我住在这儿。 This sentence points out no change. It only says that once you were living there. Your friend calls from the kitchen: 吃饭了! This one points out a change, namely that we are ready to eat the meal. It is not ...


2

It seems to me 沒有 is more formal, and 沒 is ellipsis form. I don't think they exhibit difference in usage, though. Note that 沒有 may either be "do not have/possess" (something) or "not" (adverb), depending on context. Chinese is pretty vague sometimes. Lastly, remark that, following the instance 有殺人, “有” is not mandatory and serves as a stressing word.


2

It is "我还以为你是学生" 认为 (consider; think) can be in any tense but 以为 already mean "(previously) thought" 还 is a common adverb with many meanings. In this case, it means 'even' 还以为 = '(even) thought'


2

以为 is mostly used for: wrongly thought/believed like: 我以为你死了! I thought you were dead! 觉得 is closer to: feel/think (of an opinion) like: 你这样说,我觉得非常不靠谱 What you said is totally unreasonable. 想 is close to the English: think like: 我想这个案子肯定有猫腻。 There's something fishy about this case. In Chinese the idea of English 'think' is hardly ever used - even ...


2

(今天早上) (打网球)[了] "打网球" is the fact; "今天早上" is the relative phrase that indicate what time it happened. Remove the relative phrase "今天早上" and write "我们打网球了", the sentence is still a complete sentence. (we still know you've played tennis, just don't know when) [是] ([今天早上打网球) [的] the entire phrase "今天早上打网球" is the fact If you remove the relative phrase "...


2

我长胖了=I am putting on weight. The other 3 versions are incorrect. You should reverse it to express your purpose: 我(已经)不胖了。 我曾经很胖(但现在瘦下来了)。


2

Suppose in the past I was fat, and now I'm no longer fat. You should say 我瘦下来了, 我变瘦了 or 我瘦了 in this case. 我胖了, 我变胖了 or 我长胖了 means I'm getting fat. These are incorrect: 我长胖 我长了胖 我长了胖了


2

Suppose?? All theoretical of course. 我以前很胖,现在不胖了!真的哦!


1

了 is a particle for completed action, similar to the perfect tense in English. Your sentence is in the simple past tense with no special emphasis on completion, or finishing of an action, so 了 is not necessary here. Compare these two sentences: 以前我住在这儿。 I lived here before. 我在这儿住了五年了。 I have lived here for 5 years (already).


Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible